Collections by Modern Milkman: Bottle Caps & Lids

A reusable bag labeled 'Bottle Caps & Lids' on a countertop, indicating what types of caps and lids are accepted for recycling, with illustrations for milk bottle caps, water bottle caps, pump and spray tops, and container lids.

Small caps, big difference.

Bottle caps and lids are one of the most commonly tossed recyclable items in the country, not because people don’t want to recycle them, but because most curbside programs can’t process them. They’re too small for standard sorting equipment. They fall through the gaps, literally.

Our Bottle Caps & Lids bag is designed specifically for these overlooked items. Collect them at home, fill the bag, and leave it out on delivery day. Small effort. Real impact.

How it works 

  1. Add a collection bag to your next order 
  2. When you’re ready, fill up your bag and leave it out ahead of any of your future Modern Milkman deliveries 
  3. All items must fit inside with the seal closed

Yes please:

  • Plastic milk and juice bottle caps
  • Sports drink and water bottle caps
  • Plastic container lids
  • Pump and spray tops
  • Condiment lids

No thanks:

  • Metal caps or lids
  • Glass lids
  • Dirty, wet, or food-covered items
  • Full bottles or containers

Only include items from the accepted list. Everything needs to be clean and fit in the bag with the seal closed.

What happens next

Your bag gets picked up by your milkman on their regular route. From there it travels to one of our hubs, where it goes straight into its dedicated recycling bin. We work with certified recycling partners to make sure your bottle caps and lids are processed to proper environmental standards, materials recovered, and nothing sent to landfill if there’s a better option.

Plastic caps and lids are made from high-density plastics that have genuine value as recovered material. Your bag goes to a certified facility where they’re processed properly and materials are recovered for reuse. It feels like a small thing. But when you add up the caps and lids from thousands of households, it becomes a meaningful volume of plastic kept out of the waste stream.

Caps and lids are easy to miss in the recycling process because of their small size. Every bag you fill helps keep more of these everyday plastics in the recycling stream instead of the trash.

2 responses to “Collections by Modern Milkman: Bottle Caps & Lids”

  1. […] Bottle Caps & Lids Film Plastics Hard Plastics Small Electricals […]

  2. Larry Perlstein Avatar

    Are Starbucks clear plastic polypropylene lids acceptable?

Leave a Reply

Modern Milkman

Welcome to our blog, your go-to source for recipe inspiration, product launches, sustainability tips, and all the latest updates from us!

Find us on social media

Discover more from Modern Milkman

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading